...A Coup Against Comrade Stalin?....

The theory and practice of the Profession of Arms through the ages.
Post Reply
MikeKozlowski
Posts: 2094
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 9:46 pm

...A Coup Against Comrade Stalin?....

Post by MikeKozlowski »

Intriguing commentary from https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/20 ... raine.html. I had never considered the causes (and effects) the author lays out, and though it makes sense, I'd like to hear some thoughts.

Mike

It’s not because Putin doesn’t want to take a break from the war, it’s because he can’t. Why? Because he knows Russian history not from school textbooks, but from real life.


For example, in 1825, the return of Russian troops after their victory over Napoleon led to an anti-tsarist uprising known as the Decembrist Revolt.

In 1905, Russia’s defeat in the Russo-Japanese War sparked the first Russian Revolution.


The mass desertion of Russian soldiers from the Russian-German front during World War I led to the February Revolution of 1917 and the abdication of Emperor Nicholas II.

Lenin’s March 1918 peace treaty with Germany allowed the Bolsheviks to execute the entire tsarist family.


The return of Soviet troops from Afghanistan in February 1989 marked the beginning of the USSR’s collapse.

Knowing this, Putin cannot end the war with Ukraine and bring his troops home. Only the opportunity in May 1945 to leave his entire army in Europe as an occupying force helped Stalin avoid a postwar coup. Putin, Stalin’s heir, dreams of occupying Ukraine and the Baltic states, as well as Finland and Poland, to keep his army away from Moscow. He remembers the 525,000 soldiers who returned from Afghanistan in 1989 and turned into “Afghan” bandits who terrorized the entire USSR population. Recently, in June 2023, just 5,000 rebellious Wagner Group soldiers left the Ukrainian front. Led by their commander, Yevgeny Prigozhin, they nearly stormed Moscow.
Mike
Nik_SpeakerToCats
Posts: 2250
Joined: Sat Dec 10, 2022 10:56 am

Re: ...A Coup Against Comrade Stalin?....

Post by Nik_SpeakerToCats »

Same logic applies to the Kremlin Oligarchy: They'd be first against the firing wall...
Question akin to wondering how many 'Putin Puppets' are out there...

IIRC, he has apparently been spotted 'bi-locational', but no-one took a shot at either...
If you cannot see the wood for the trees, deploy LIDAR.
User avatar
Sukhoiman
Posts: 1093
Joined: Sun Nov 20, 2022 5:09 am

Re: ...A Coup Against Comrade Stalin?....

Post by Sukhoiman »

Earlier convo elsewhere on same theme:

reminds me of the immense difficulty Mao and CCP had with korean war PLA veterans, rehabilitating them back into normie life

mao kind of didnt see is that way, given expenses needed to do that....so in essence he kept veteran loyalty with commisar groups and unleashing them on civvies to carry out great leap forward (and forced "kulak" appropriations before it just like stalin did with holodomor), cultural revolution and so on....creating local civil wars basically to keep them active and bash up civvies that offered any resistance.

This psycho scar effect and totalitarian setup is common theme in both landmasses that saw mongols run roughshod and legacy of it in monarchy afterwards. The republic to come after monarchy remains neo-monarchy... religions are replaced with neo-religions (marxist despot cultism) and so on, all to perpetrate the bunker fear complex the elitists have developed from getting shellacked by mongols to that degree. There will always be "neo-mongols" lurking around imaginary or real...and this got further strengthened with the actions of Japan and Germany in ww2 for these landmasses.

And so we see the bullying of ukraine and taiwan and anything that is "splintered off". Taiwan just has natural extreme barrier in between....ukraine doesnt. Thats ukraines saddest problem now.
Belushi TD
Posts: 1706
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 11:20 am

Re: ...A Coup Against Comrade Stalin?....

Post by Belushi TD »

And remember the source.

American Thinker is not known for its..... accuracy.

Belushi TD
Micael
Posts: 6706
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 10:50 am

Re: ...A Coup Against Comrade Stalin?....

Post by Micael »

This scenario has been proposed earlier during the war. I wouldn’t call it unrealistic, but I’m not sure that it’s a given that it would occur either.
Nightwatch2
Posts: 2190
Joined: Fri Nov 18, 2022 4:50 am

Re: ...A Coup Against Comrade Stalin?....

Post by Nightwatch2 »

Micael wrote: Mon Oct 20, 2025 4:17 pm This scenario has been proposed earlier during the war. I wouldn’t call it unrealistic, but I’m not sure that it’s a given that it would occur either.
Nor that the new regime would be any different
Post Reply