Star Trek TOS

Good books? Great Films? Good television? Best Music? Or those that really need avoidance? This is where to review and comment on new fact or fiction.
Post Reply
User avatar
jemhouston
Posts: 6591
Joined: Fri Nov 18, 2022 12:38 am

Star Trek TOS

Post by jemhouston »

Over in the The Last War: 355, this exchanged happened. Rather than reply in that, I decided to start a new one
Jotun wrote: ↑Mon Feb 27, 2023 8:19 pmNow that I had my first infection with that "unidentified virus of unknown origin" as the Critical Drinker puts it, followed by three weeks of a nasty f***ing bronchitis that finally seems to subside, I may just find the energy to get back into the saddle.
Ill health is never fun. I can certainly confirm that. Had a horrible migrane over the weekend and today. Btw, I get the impression that the Critical Drinker is a wee bit of, as we would say in Scotland, a bawbag. He has criticised modern Star Trek and Doctor Who for being 'woke'. Has he seen the classic shows? They were 'woke' AF for their era! :lol:
Jotun wrote: ↑Mon Feb 27, 2023 8:19 pmThanks for the update and glad to be of service.
Star Trek TOS were woke for their time, but they didn't beat your head over with it. Ultimate Computer, Kirk called Dr. Richard Daystrom Sir. Remember this was the mid 60s

Image

Same thing in Court Martial.
Jotun
Posts: 1497
Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2022 8:27 pm
Location: Ze Bocage Mudflats

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Jotun »

I am certain that the Drinker is fine with the older efforts of Star Trek and Dr Who.
Yes, the old stuff was woke AF for its time but it was…elegant about it. There was no tokenism, no box ticking, no gender-switching, no "strong female protagonists" that were little more than Mary Sues who are contrasted against lecherous, thuggish and inept men in order to make them shine that much brighter (and failing abysmally at it).
Modern "woke" entertainment suffers from extremely shitty writing and that does seem to be what grieves him the most…
The shitty writing comes from a bunch of young, opinionated "I studied something with media" people with no experience, little talent, no willingless to learn, an unchecked ego and a metric f***ton of personal hangups, grievances and pet peeves they urgently wish to address at the cost of a good story.
Johnnie Lyle
Posts: 4098
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 2:27 pm

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Johnnie Lyle »

Jotun wrote: ↑Mon Feb 27, 2023 9:18 pm I am certain that the Drinker is fine with the older efforts of Star Trek and Dr Who.
Yes, the old stuff was woke AF for its time but it was…elegant about it. There was no tokenism, no box ticking, no gender-switching, no "strong female protagonists" that were little more than Mary Sues who are contrasted against lecherous, thuggish and inept men in order to make them shine that much brighter (and failing abysmally at it).
Modern "woke" entertainment suffers from extremely shitty writing and that does seem to be what grieves him the most…
The shitty writing comes from a bunch of young, opinionated "I studied something with media" people with no experience, little talent, no willingless to learn, an unchecked ego and a metric f***ton of personal hangups, grievances and pet peeves they urgently wish to address at the cost of a good story.
The old-fashioned socialist novel or other kinds of social issue literature was designed to be enthralling and entertaining, and thus the social commentary and mind changing goes down much easier and more effectively.

If anything, that’s the entire point of sci-fi and fantasy literature. It makes social commentary a lot more palatable and easier to accept because it’s not a direct attack on the reader.

As long as the story doesn’t suck. Unfortunately, a lot of “woke” stuff (in any medium) really doesn’t understand how to persuade people and change minds, so it’s very unentertaining unless it’s your particular jam.

The shocking bit with the Critical Drinker is that he likes Picard Season 3 so far.
Bernard Woolley
Posts: 1547
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 4:06 pm
Location: Earth

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Bernard Woolley »

No gender switching? Other than that episode when a woman switched genders with Kirk. :lol:
“Frankly, I had enjoyed the war… and why do people want peace if the war is so much fun?” - Lieutenant General Sir Adrian Carton de Wiart
Johnnie Lyle
Posts: 4098
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 2:27 pm

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Johnnie Lyle »

Bernard Woolley wrote: ↑Tue Feb 28, 2023 3:19 am No gender switching? Other than that episode when a woman switched genders with Kirk. :lol:
She was also an absolutely crackers homicidal maniac and proved why she was poorly suited to the Big Chair. It’s hardly a ringing endorsement of the concept 8-)

Being serious, Star Trek is full of examples of how to present a social issue in a matter of fact way, and to emphasize our joined humanity. The most successful are often the simplest, such as Chekov, Sulu, Uhura, Geordi or Worf.

Maybe our parents and grandparents were smarter than we thought/want to admit. :lol:
Simon Darkshade
Posts: 2185
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 10:55 am

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Simon Darkshade »

Further to that, I believe that the episode in question was the 79th and final episode of the TOS. I don't believe that the circumstances of that episode could be seen as representative of the other ones of TOS, which I believe was Jotun's meaning when he listed characteristics of it. I certainly don't think the events of Turnabout Intruder invalidate his description of what TOS did and did not have.

I would similarly say that TOS of Star Trek and the first incarnation of Doctor Who (1963-1989) managed to "do" their politics, social commentary and themes in a more sophisticated, grown up and creative manner; modern versions of both, like many other shows on the electric television, tend more towards the antithesis of sophistication, creativity and maturity in their treatment of such issues.

In addition, I fully endorse Jotun's characterisation of The Critical Drinker as one who is more grieved by the poverty of writing and the poverty of ideas than the fact that they simply express THE MESSAGE. I have viewed all of his stuff since 2019, which is a fairly considerable opus, and he does go into quite detailed and thoughtful analysis of how and why modern films, television shows and games are bad; it would be a mistake for any potential viewer to get hung up on his character flourishes. Indeed, some of his 'out of character' videos discussing media are quite sophisticated and refreshing for those who eschew his particular type of comedy.
gtg947h
Posts: 317
Joined: Sun Nov 20, 2022 10:49 am
Location: Savannah

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by gtg947h »

It's one thing to present something in a matter-of-fact way and just move on. TOS, The Expanse, etc. do this well. It's quite another to bash your audience over the head with a flashing neon sign saying "look how woke I am!" which is what appears to be most of the point of the "woke" movement (or really, many/most social movements across the political spectrum). It's more important to be seen saying the right things and proclaiming your adherence to a particular ideology than to actually act in the way the movement is ostensibly intended to promote.
User avatar
jemhouston
Posts: 6591
Joined: Fri Nov 18, 2022 12:38 am

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by jemhouston »

gtg947h wrote: ↑Tue Feb 28, 2023 11:53 am It's one thing to present something in a matter-of-fact way and just move on. TOS, The Expanse, etc. do this well. It's quite another to bash your audience over the head with a flashing neon sign saying "look how woke I am!" which is what appears to be most of the point of the "woke" movement (or really, many/most social movements across the political spectrum). It's more important to be seen saying the right things and proclaiming your adherence to a particular ideology than to actually act in the way the movement is ostensibly intended to promote.
That's why people are tuning out.
Jotun
Posts: 1497
Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2022 8:27 pm
Location: Ze Bocage Mudflats

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Jotun »

jemhouston wrote: ↑Tue Feb 28, 2023 1:20 pm
gtg947h wrote: ↑Tue Feb 28, 2023 11:53 am It's one thing to present something in a matter-of-fact way and just move on. TOS, The Expanse, etc. do this well. It's quite another to bash your audience over the head with a flashing neon sign saying "look how woke I am!" which is what appears to be most of the point of the "woke" movement (or really, many/most social movements across the political spectrum). It's more important to be seen saying the right things and proclaiming your adherence to a particular ideology than to actually act in the way the movement is ostensibly intended to promote.
That's why people are tuning out.
This and the execrable writing (and acting). Just look at how many flagship movies and series tanked in the last years because THE MESSAGE took precedence over everything. And everybody who dared dislike the utter crap that was presented to the public was accused of every f***ing -ism under the f***ing sun.
Just look at what they did to Tolkien in Rings of Power. Or what about She-Hulk? Or the new Scooby Doo series without Scooby Doo in it but full of self-inserted ego by the Velma voice actress whose name escapes me atm. The Star Wars sequel trilogy. And so many other crippled franchises.
Bernard Woolley
Posts: 1547
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 4:06 pm
Location: Earth

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Bernard Woolley »

TOS and Classic Who were subtle because they had to be. Although, not always. IMVHO, modern audiences are less attuned to subtlety.

ST and NuWho are still very capable of telling good stories.
“Frankly, I had enjoyed the war… and why do people want peace if the war is so much fun?” - Lieutenant General Sir Adrian Carton de Wiart
Jotun
Posts: 1497
Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2022 8:27 pm
Location: Ze Bocage Mudflats

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Jotun »

Bernard Woolley wrote: ↑Tue Feb 28, 2023 2:56 pm TOS and Classic Who were subtle because they had to be. Although, not always. IMVHO, modern audiences are less attuned to subtlety.

ST and NuWho are still very capable of telling good stories.
"Modern audiences" havr a significant percentage of ambiguity refuseniks in their ranks. But they are a loud and obnoxious minority.
Johnnie Lyle
Posts: 4098
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 2:27 pm

Re: Star Trek TOS

Post by Johnnie Lyle »

Bernard Woolley wrote: ↑Tue Feb 28, 2023 2:56 pm TOS and Classic Who were subtle because they had to be. Although, not always. IMVHO, modern audiences are less attuned to subtlety.
I wouldn’t say it was subtle. Uhura was not subtle. Nor was Chekov. But they were presented matter of factly. Same with someone like Barney Collier in Mission Impossible - or possibly even more so.

I’m not sure modern audiences are less tuned to subtlety. I think it’s more about writers and directors who are not understanding subtlety. When it is used (
Spoiler!
such as how they handled the reveal of Jack Crusher
), audiences and critics love it. That was all acting; the only overt dialogue was
Spoiler!
Riker asking Picard if he saw it, then Picard’s admission at the end.
Honestly, I’d say Picard Season 3 is very heavily using subtlety instead of explicit hammering home the message. Hopefully it holds up.
Bernard Woolley wrote: ↑Tue Feb 28, 2023 2:56 pm ST and NuWho are still very capable of telling good stories.
Aye, but they’re also capable of overplaying their hand. Too often stuff tells instead of shows, and Trek can be pretty smug at times, especially Jean-Luc Picard. He gets preachy, which can be hilarious but is also off putting - people don’t like to be lectured. I like that Picard uses that to address Picard as a flawed man, and to show he may still be in the 2360s when the rest of the universe is in the 2390s/2400s, but TNG played it straight.
Post Reply